Saturday, 14 December 2024

MUCH ADO ABOUT KEMI

Having spent a significant amount of time in my formative years in Lagos and also having a lot of Yoruba friends. I have long admired their strong ethnic identity. They are first Yoruba before anything; Religion, Nationality etc all come a distant second. So like jews wherever they find themselves in the world, they hold on to their culture and do their best to raise their kids as Yoruba. They are mostly very successful and make Nigeria proud. There is absolutely nothing wrong with being proud of your Yoruba heritage and celebrating it. Just as a Hindi was Prime Minister, we hope that a Yoruba woman will be Prime Minister and Amala will be served in Downing Street. The British Empire has come full cycle and it is our turn, Emilokan.


I watched in mild amusement the reactions of a cross section of Nigerians to the latest attempt by Kemi Badenoch to distance herself from her Nigerian identity. She said that she identifies more as Yoruba than Nigerian as she has nothing in common with the Northern part of Nigeria, who are islamists and the home of Boko Haram. Had she stopped at identifying more as Yoruba than Nigerian and even saying she had nothing in common with the North, no one will bat an eyelid. However, she had to stick the knife by basically painting the entire Northern Nigeria as Islamists and Boko Haram members. This is completely unacceptable and it stands condemned.


I do however kind of respect her for speaking her mind and expressing opinions held by so many others, in the diaspora and in Nigeria. The truth is that we are yet to form a national identity, despite the progress we have made since independence. Our ethnic and religious differences are the biggest obstacles in forging this identity. I used to be a dreamer and I truly believed that Nigeria will be united. Unfortunately it's looking more like the younger generation look even more divided if the vile online debates are anything to go by, fuelled by ignorance and passed down generational hate. It's sure difficult to have a national identity, the USA despite having a very strong brand have shown in recent times that the country is deeply divided along so many lines. There may be hope for Nigeria or not. I am more open to these things than I used to before.


For every Kemi Badenoch, you have an Anthony Joshua and Bukayo Saka (I had to do that). Proof that you can be British (or whatever) and not drag Nigeria in the mud anytime a microphone is thrust in front of you. Again, you can also be proud of your ethnic identity and acquired identity without ignorantly smearing others.


Abdulmalik Mahdi

Thursday, 5 December 2024

Tax Reforms - the Elephant in the room

 In my opinion, this Tax Reform Bill debate is the latest manifestation of the deep issues with our federation. This is normal for a country that is less than a hundred years old and has so many diverse people. From time to time, critical issues arise that force the component parts in every country to negotiate with each other and agree on acceptable terms. This is especially crucial for countries such as Nigeria where these conversations did not really happen in the very beginning.


Yes we had constitutional conferences in London under colonial supervision and instruction, but so many issues were swept under the carpet precisely because of that. Some of these issues led to the Civil War and many crisis in the life of the nation.


To my mind, at the very core of these issues is the feeling that some parts of the country are a burden on the rest of the federation and the others feel that at best every one should support himself, regions/states should develop at their own pace, a weaker federal government and greater control of resources by the states. Their position is that Resources should be shared based on derivation, not equality of states or population. While it was possible to surpress these agitations in past especially under the military, it is impossible for to keep kicking the can down the road forever especially in this day and age of information technology and democracy. 


The States that feel strongly against any sort of restructuring, fiscal or political, have very limited time to accept the reality of these happening whether they like it or not. The best they can do is to negotiate a slower process that allows them reposition their states and region to be more competitive in the new federation that will emerge sooner rather than later. I hope that is what they are doing because this crisis is only shining a light on the fact or reinforcing the belief that without FAAC and VAT they cannot survive, not viable and not bringing value (pun intended) to the table. 


Next year we are going to have a census, if you think this tax reform matter is a crisis, you haven't seen anything yet. A lot of things in Nigeria today are based on population, from revenue allocation to political representation in the number of constituencies, local governments, states, number of ministers, judicial appointments and National Assembly members etc. The infamous quota system, equality of states and population. Constituent parts of the federation have always accused each other of trying to gain unfair advantage by inflating their population. We have all heard allegations of livestock being counted in North for example made popular by the South West press. So to expect it to be a smooth process is fanciful at best but foolish if we are being realistic. 


The President is representing a constituency that has from the beginning of this journey in 1960 always called for the reform of the country along the lines above. The long military rule had truncated those aspirations for so long, but now that he is in the saddle, he looks determined shape the destiny of the nation more than any other president before. Tinubu will attempt to achieve restructuring Nigeria via reforms since constitutional conferences have failed to achieve the goals of the South West or address the agitations of marginalization by South East or environmental degradation of the South South or the political aspirations of the North Central Christian minorities. That is going to be the legacy of President Tinubu. 


Whether the Northern Governors like it or not, this Tax Reform Bill is not the last attempt at restructuring by PBAT. It is up to them as the political leaders of the north and the custodians of the vision of Sardauna to liberate their people from the shackles of poverty, disease, illiteracy and terrorism. No one is going to do it for us, whether in Nigeria as we know it today or in any future political union in the future. The handwriting has been on the wall for a while now, but as they say 'Objects in mirrors are closer than they appear'.


Abdulmalik Mahdi

Abuja, Nigeria